#peer-review
Peer review by committee? New journal rethinks old model
Suspicious phrases in peer reviews point to referees gaming the system | Science | AAAS
Peer review is essential for science. Unfortunately, it’s broken. | Ars Technica
How Should We Critique Research?
what makes a criticism important is how much it could change a result if corrected and how much that would then change our decisions or actions: to what extent it is a “difference which makes a difference”.